Is Middle Island, NY 11953 a buyer’s or seller’s market?
Middle Island is a seller’s market. With about 2.5 months of supply and 59% of recent sales closing above the original list price, competing offers are common on well-priced homes. Buyers here often have a pre-approval in hand and a plan for the appraisal gap before touring.
#61 of 125 ZIP codes in Nassau & Suffolk counties, NY, and #281 of 531 across all the markets we track.
Based on share sold above original list, sale-to-list ratio, months of supply and days on market for the 3 months ending August 31, 2026. How the heat score works
The Middle Island housing market right now
In the three months ending August 31, 2026, 59% of homes in Middle Island, NY 11953 sold above their list price, the typical home went under contract in 22 days and there were 2.5 months of supply. Under four months of supply means sellers have the edge: expect competition for well-priced homes. That’s based on 63 home sales.
Compared with the same period a year earlier, the share selling over asking was about the same (59% then), homes sold faster (35 days then) and the median sale price rose 11% to $469,797. Overall, Middle Island is more competitive than a year ago, so tougher for buyers.
Within Suffolk County, homes here sell faster than in 76% of the county’s ZIP codes, and sell more often over asking than in 51%. On our competition score, Middle Island ranks #247 of 649 NY ZIP codes with enough sales (score 85 out of 100).
Nearby, buyers who want less competition could look at Westhampton 11977 (0% sold over asking) or Water Mill 11976 (0% sold over asking), while West Sayville 11796 (100% sold over asking) and Peconic 11958 (100% sold over asking) are even more competitive.
Run the numbers for 11953
Nearby markets
Amagansett 11930Balanced $988 /sq ftAmityville 11701Seller’s market $442 /sq ftBabylon 11702Seller’s market $455 /sq ftBay Shore 11706Seller’s market $426 /sq ft Browse all markets →Towns like Middle Island nearby
Find towns like Middle Island in other states →Where Middle Island is
Loading map…
Questions about Middle Island real estate
Is Middle Island a buyer’s or seller’s market?
A seller’s market: there were 2.5 months of supply in Middle Island, NY 11953 in the three months ending August 31, 2026. Under four months usually favors sellers, and more than six favors buyers.
How fast do homes sell in Middle Island?
The typical home went under contract in 22 days in the latest three months.
Do homes in Middle Island sell over asking?
59% of homes sold above their original list price, and the typical sale closed at 101.8% of the list price.
What are property taxes in Middle Island?
About 1.73% of a home’s value a year in Suffolk County, or roughly $6,920 on a $400,000 home.
What is the median home price in Middle Island?
The median sale price was $469,797 in the three months ending August 31, 2026, about $304 per square foot.
Local agents
See all agents in 11953 →No sponsored agents in 11953 yet. Are you an agent here? Put your name in front of local buyers.
More tools for 11953
Market data describes housing activity only. Figures are rolling 3-month values from Redfin and may be revised. Methodology